Thunderbolts (The New Avengers)

Thunderbolts is a messy, joyless MCU team-up carried almost entirely by Florence Pugh and David Harbour’s charisma.
414009
Starring
Florence Pugh, David Harbour, Sebastian Stan
Director
Jake Schreier
Rating
PG-13
Genre
Action, Adventure, Crime, Drama, Sci-Fi
Release date
May 2, 2025
Overall Score
Rating Overview
Story/Plot/Script
Visuals/Cinematography
Performance
Direction
Non-Wokeness
Rating Summary
Without David Harbour, this unfocused and desperate attempt at building another team franchise would be nothing more than a mean-spirited and depressing slog. As it is, his big and boisterous enthusiasm gives Thunderbolts just enough personality to maybe make it worth a single viewing once it hits Disney+ (if, for some reason you're still giving them your money.)

In Thunderbolts (The New Avengers), CIA Director Valentina Allegra de Fontaine, facing impeachment, assembles a team of antiheroes—Yelena Belova, John Walker, Ghost, and Taskmaster—and sends them to a remote compound. There, they’re ambushed in a deadly trap designed to eliminate them. With help from Alexei Shostakov, who dubs them the “Thunderbolts,” they escape and join forces with Bucky Barnes to confront de Fontaine. However, their mission uncovers the existence of Bob, a powerful superhuman known as Sentry, whose dark alter ego, the Void, poses a catastrophic threat to New York City.

Thunderbolts (The New Avengers) Review

As a sad and tired looking Bucky Barns gets savagely beaten with his own arm by a clinically depressed meth addict who can only be stopped by getting in touch with his feelings, while tertiary MCU female characters belittle their loser male counterparts, audiences will ask themselves, “why is Thunderbolts?”

With disasters like The Marvels and Captain America: Brave New World still fresh in our collective minds, by comparison, moments of Thunderbolts are a breath of fresh air, while others are stark reminders of how far the franchise has fallen. David Harbour’s Red Guardian is one thing the film gets right. He’s big and bold and having far too much fun for such a melancholy movie, but his shining optimism, childish though it may be, will be the only thing keeping audience members from contemplating the business end of a revolver during Thunderbolts’ more than two hours of loneliness and depression.

X Marks the Spot - Follow us Today!!

Thunderbolts is a bit of a misnomer (but not as much as The New Avengers), as the film is a Yelena Belova movie with other characters in it. Even fan-favorite Bucky Barnes is more or less an afterthought. If you don’t know who Yelena is, it’s the Florence Pugh character that the MCU is desperate to have fill ScarJo’s leather catsuit. And while Florence Pugh is an exceptional actress, she ain’t filling that thing out. In any case, no amount of talent or even a pinup figure would make her itty bitty parkour, kung fu character make sense in a universe that also has Celestials.

That aside, structurally, the film is messy. It’s bloated with two-dimensional characters who all serve more or less the same narrative purpose, and it doesn’t know what to do with those who are on an adventure that doesn’t feel natural. The action set-pieces don’t make sense, especially when the group confronts Sentry. After unloading magazines (plural) of 50-caliber rounds and super-soldier roundhouses without budging the golden-maned schizophrenic, the ragtag group of street-level heroes literally take their knives to a Superman fight. Worse than that, the fight goes on forever. But hey, they do manage to throw out snarky one-liners like rounds from a Gatling gun. That’s pretty much the formula throughout.

The action is unimaginative, the characters are forgettable, and the plot is little more than a commercial for the next MCU product. Thunderbolts is a culmination of some of the MCU’s worst instincts bolstered by a couple of really talented performers and first-rate special effects, but otherwise, it is a complete waste, and it seems to know it. I don’t want to spoil the post-credit scene, but it acknowledges all of this and perfectly encapsulates what I was feeling by the film’s end.

If you’re desperate for a big-budget special effects superhero movie and are in a forgiving mood, maybe Thunderbolts will do it for you. But The Accountant 2 is still out there, and it’s a lot more fun than this.

Woke Report

WOKE REPORT

You're Only Getting Half the Picture.

This section is our site's secret sauce, and what truly separates us from the rest. If you don't read it, you haven't read our review.

Have the filmmakers chosenradical progressive messaging over story?
Unlock the insightsthat could change your viewing experience and protect your family.

James Carrick

James Carrick is a passionate film enthusiast with a degree in theater and philosophy. James approaches dramatic criticism from a philosophic foundation grounded in aesthetics and ethics, offering insight and analysis that reveals layers of cinematic narrative with a touch of irreverence and a dash of snark.

Leave a Review
  1. aroh100876 May 2, 2025 at

    Wouldn’t this being more of the M-She-U where all women are perfect and all men are idiots make this movie a lot more woke than only 25%?

    1. James Carrick May 2, 2025 at

      It’s all a matter of perception. In my opinion, the frequency of the infractions and their impact on the film detrimentally affected/infected 25% of the film. If it had been more focused and less of a mess, with the same about of M-She-Uness, it would have made a greater impact. But, the reason that I include a detailed list of the woke elements in addition to just a blanket score, is because everyone perceives things differently. This way everyone can read exactly what occurs in the film and make a decision for themselves.

      P.S. Are you going to eat a sandwich that’s 25% crap?

      3
      1
  2. _JB_ July 4, 2025 at

    Thanks, not paying a dime for this.

  3. [email protected] August 30, 2025 at

    Truth be told, I think you’re a bit too harsh on this one (with all due respect). I just watched it once now that it’s streaming on Disney+ as you advised, but it didn’t come off as woke to me.

    Yes, Yelena is a tiny girl who benefits from courteous bad guys, but that’s about it. The two other girl bosses (de Fontaine and her assistant) aren’t shown in a great light for their girl bossiness. de Fontaine is very unlikable and her assistant feels like a fish out of water (intentionally so). And Ghost (the remaining major female character), has cool powers that are used to good effect and she doesn’t snark like the other three.

    Re the guys:
    1. US Agent is haunted by his failings as a father and husband, but that’s a good thing. Not that he’s a failure, but that he yearns to be greater than he is.
    2. Red Guardian is the only communist I’ve ever liked. I even thought there was a great parallel to him and Gorbichov in the supermarket marveling at “all the choices.”
    3. Bucky is classic Bucky which I liked. He even had that solid joke about his past – again pointing out that he’s trying to rise above his past failures.
    4. Bob’s performance was really good, similar themes as the other guys (plus Yelena) – rising above their past failures.

    I know you watched in theaters, but maybe give it another shot on D+.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

No audience reviews yet. Be the first to leave one.

 

X Marks the Spot - Follow us Today!!

 

 

'; win.document.open(); win.document.write(html); win.document.close(); return true; } function escapeHtml(str){ return String(str || '').replace(/[&<>"']/g, function(ch){ return ({'&':'&','<':'<','>':'>','"':'"',"'":'''})[ch] || ch; }); } function renderShareOptionsWindow(win, landscapeUrl, squareUrl, shareUrl, heading){ if (!win || win.closed) return false; var safeHeading = escapeHtml(heading || 'Share options'); var safeLandscape = escapeHtml(landscapeUrl || ''); var safeSquare = escapeHtml(squareUrl || ''); var safeUrl = escapeHtml(shareUrl || ''); var html = '' + '' + '' + safeHeading + '' + '' + '
' + '

' + safeHeading + '

' + '' + '' + '
' + '