
- Starring
- Peter Claffey, Dexter Sol Ansell, Daniel Ings
- Creators
- George R.R. Martin, Ira Parker
- Rating
- TV-MA
- Genre
- Action, Adventure, Drama, Fantasy
- Release date
- Jan 18, 2026
- Where to watch
- HBO Max
Overall Score
Rating Overview
Rating Summary
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms follows the wandering adventures of a towering, earnest hedge knight named Ser Duncan the Tall—known simply as Dunk—and his clever, diminutive squire, Egg. Set about a century before the events of Game of Thrones, in an era when the Targaryen dynasty still rules the Iron Throne and dragons linger in living memory, the tale traces their unlikely friendship through tournaments, mishaps, and encounters with nobility, where great destinies and hidden secrets quietly unfold amid the everyday struggles of Westeros’s lesser roads.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (season 1) REVIEW
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Review (S1:E1)›
It's not a long episode, and not a lot happens, but what does could end up going either way. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms lacks the gravitas (at least so far) of either of its progenitor series, and seemingly intentionally so. If you go into it looking for the same raw intensity as the original or House of the Dragon, you're likely to be disappointed.
Instead of bloody political intrigue and sexual perversion, AKOTSK gives us a hopeful and earnest would-be knight... and diarrhea. I wish the latter were hyperbole. It is not.
As of yet, the narrative ground on which the story stands is uneven and fractious, with moments of poignancy unnecessarily punctuated by Joss Whedon–esque juvenility—albeit with an R-rated flair. There is also a gossamer-thin patina of inchoateness to much of the episode. It’s subtle, but unmistakably present.
In practical terms, this manifests in a series of small but cumulative misalignments. Some key performers don’t quite connect with the material, most notably the young boy who plays Egg. He’s a young actor, and perhaps one day he’ll mature into a strong one, but for now the role seems just slightly beyond his grasp. Even the background performances occasionally feel off, with extras adopting artificial limps or exaggerated physicality that draws attention rather than blending naturally into the world.
Individually, these are minor issues. Taken together, they lend the production an almost Renaissance-fair quality—close to convincing, but not fully inhabited—rather than the grounded authority of a top-tier fantasy series.
However, there is one aspect that could carry the production through to the end. The premise. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is a classic tale of an unassuming underdog, and Peter Claffey, who plays our Knight in question, while slow to build momentum, ends the episode with the audience rooting for him. If the show can maintain its current level, it has the potential to be a fun little diversion.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Review (S1:E2-3)›
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Review (S1:E4)›

There hasn't been a movie or show worth adding to our Role Models list since last October, and even then, it took a biographical movie about people standing up to Nazis to get it, and while, with two episodes left, there's certainly enough time left in the season for things to change, I hope you'll excuse me this one conceit. Sir Duncan the Tall is the hero we both need and deserve.
In the first episode of the season to forego gratuitous vulgarity, Seven's focused storytelling gives audiences one of the most enjoyable episodes of TV in months. All it took was competent direction, a decent story unencumbered by the personal politics of its showrunners, and an earnest and brave underdog. Duncan, played by 6'5" Peter Claffey, isn't the star of the show merely because he is the star. Rather, he is the embodiment of much of what men want to be. He's good because it's right, not out of a sense of guilt or as a middle finger to a cruel society that he holds himself above. He's kind and understanding and slow to anger, but none of this is at the cost of his lethal potential. Instead, he wishes to wield that potential on behalf of those who cannot do so themselves.
It's an insanely simple formula that consistently pleases audiences and sells tickets, but it's not one that modern Hollywood is often willing to entertain.
In an earlier critique of the show, I lamented that A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms appeared to be yet another show suffering from too little story artificially stretched across too many episodes, albeit done better than most. However, now that we are approaching the conclusion, and I have the benefit of hindsight, I'm forced to amend that opinion for the simple reason that each episode leaves me wanting more and looking forward to the next one.
I'm left to conclude that the problem isn't the content but the episode length. Were I someone reading this and having not yet watched an episode, I would wait for two weeks and binge them all at once.
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Review (S1:E5-6)›

WOKE REPORT
You're Only Getting Half the Picture.
This section is our site's secret sauce, and what truly separates us from the rest. If you don't read it, you haven't read our review.
Help us fight the Woke Mind Virus. Join today.
James Carrick
James Carrick is a passionate film enthusiast with a degree in theater and philosophy. James approaches dramatic criticism from a philosophic foundation grounded in aesthetics and ethics, offering insight and analysis that reveals layers of cinematic narrative with a touch of irreverence and a dash of snark.






Agree with everything you wrote here except I thought the little dude playing Egg was fine. He was barely in the episode, so we’ll have to wait and see how he does as the adventure continues. In my amateur opinion, though, he carried that final scene as the two talked in Dunk’s makeshift camp. As for the overall story, it has been a couple years since I read the three novellas that make up the Dunk and Egg tales, but I remember them being fun adventure stories in the vein of GoT, but more heroic and less – not sure I am using the right word here – severe. Still, there were moments of GoT gore and tragedy and some vestiges of the politics of the land leaked into the tales, but the focus was on exploration, friendship, chivalry, and fun. I liked all three stories, but the Hedge Knight, the first story upon which the first season of the TV show is seemingly based, was the most GoT-ish. If there are woke elements in the show, they will be purely manufactured by the showrunner/director because the novellas were mostly based. After just one episode, the show seems to be following suit.
After three episodes, I’d say it is still mostly good and mostly based. I keep waiting for the roof to cave in, but instead the show is seemingly getting better. While not 100% faithful to the source material, the show is faithful to the spirit of it. I hope they can keep it going – and maybe eliminate the more “left field” moments (a couple examples mentioned in the main review and Woke Notes), that don’t really add anything other than shock value to the narrative. Just stick to the tremendous bond of friendship developing between our two heroes and the chivalrous, exciting things they do together.
I’m a fan through the first four episodes. I’ll finish the last two next week. This show has an almost all male cast and as you say the main characters are not only likeable but also of good character. It’s one of the only shows in recent years that is not filled with the gender politics or a Mary Sue type of character. I’m glad it is popular and hopefully its success sends a message to the networks and streaming services that audiences are hungry for shows with good men and no overly political overtones.
Highly recommended. There is little here to complain about. Finally a new series that has no distracting social agenda items or forced diversity casting. Just a solid adventure story that embraces and extols the spirit of chivalry and friendship highlighted in the novella. Easily one of the best shows in recent memory. I am certain season two will be filled with everything WioW fans loathe – no way HBO can let let things continue in this fashion. But until then, feel free to enjoy the first season – it is definitely worth your time.
No audience reviews yet. Be the first to leave one.