Moana 2

Moana 2 is a visually gorgeous but shallow sequel that rehashes the original with weaker characters, less heart, and a forgettable adventure.
311259
Starring
Dwayne Johnson, Auli'i Cravalho, Alan Tudyk
Directors
David G. Derrick Jr, Jason Hand, Dana Ledoux Miller
Rating
PG
Genre
Adventure Animation, Comedy, Family, Fantasy
Release date
Nov 27, 2024
Overall Score
Rating Overview
Story/Plot/Script
Visuals/Cinematography
Performance
Direction
Age Appropriate
Parent Appeal
Non-Wokeness
Rating Summary
A less focused, beat-for-beat rehash of the original, Moana 2 feels overstuffed with dull secondary characters and underdeveloped in nearly every aspect. If you’re not already tired of the “independent girl defies historical norms to embark on a solo adventure” trope, you might still find enjoyment in the vibrant visuals and well-performed—albeit forgettable—music.

Moana 2 kicks off three years after the original, throwing the Polynesian Wayfinder into a whole new quest. This time, Moana is on a mission to lift the curse of Nalo, which has left island communities cut off and struggling. Her goal? To track down the legendary island of Motufetu, which is said to bring different cultures together. With a fresh crew of wayfinders and plenty of challenges—including face-offs with the underworld goddess Matangi—Moana dives headfirst into another adventure.

Moana 2 Review

Clocking in at an hour and forty minutes (three minutes shorter than the 2016 hit), one might think that Moana 2 would be a tightly structured adventure that gets to the point quickly and takes its audience on an economical and enjoyable journey that expands on the goodwill earned by the first. Unfortunately, it appears that the writers ran out of ideas and opted to redo the first, but with more characters and less character growth.

In this sequel, Moana is a fully realized woman who is super-awesome and super happy with her life until she finds a piece of pottery that convinces her that life could be even better by inviting countless unvetted strangers into her people’s world. Mind you, that her island appears to be prospering and full of happy island folk. So, off she goes on some vaguely important journey to face off against an unknown and undeveloped foe who amounts to little more than a big storm/boss battle in the film’s final moments. However, along the way, she will amass a crew consisting of undeveloped and uninteresting people whose presence on an ocean-spanning adventure makes no sense, save perhaps the one who builds ships. You’ve got your weak, old, grumpy man, a 90 lbs woman who can cut through thick masts with a single chop of her stone hand scythe for some reason, and a strapping but otherwise useless young man who paints pictures.

There is nothing organic about her crew’s assemblage. Instead, we are clumsily introduced to each member on her home island, and they are then made her crew. But let not your heart be troubled; there are all kinds of meaningless adventures ahead.

A cartoon film doesn’t necessarily need well-fleshed-out and reasonable characters to be enjoyable as long as the adventure is compelling. In the forty minutes allotted to the movie’s adventure, Moana and her crew will encounter no fewer than two antagonists who actually want her to succeed and only pretend to be obstacles for vague reasons before letting her and her crew go.

And Maui is there.

Nothing in Moana 2 is earned. What plot there is doesn’t make any sense, and the characters are little more than plot conveniences used to get us to the next musical number. So, if beautiful visuals and forgettable but well-done songs are enough for you, Moana 2 might be your holiday family film.

 

Parental Notes

PARENTAL NOTES

Important Information for Parents

Our Parental Notes flag the material parents may want to know about before pressing play, including profanity, blasphemy, adult content, extreme violence, frightening intensity, hyper-stimulating sequences, and other family-content concerns.

UNLOCK PARENTAL NOTES.Profanity, blasphemy, adult content, extreme violence, hyper-stimulating intensity, and more.
Woke Report

WOKE REPORT

You're Only Getting Half the Picture.

This section is our site's secret sauce, and what truly separates us from the rest. If you don't read it, you haven't read our review.

Have the filmmakers chosenradical progressive messaging over story?
Unlock the insightsthat could change your viewing experience and protect your family.

James Carrick

James Carrick is a passionate film enthusiast with a degree in theater and philosophy. James approaches dramatic criticism from a philosophic foundation grounded in aesthetics and ethics, offering insight and analysis that reveals layers of cinematic narrative with a touch of irreverence and a dash of snark.

Leave a Review
  1. marshalllangdon December 1, 2024 at

    I honestly didn’t think this film was woke, and I have no tolerance for wokeness in kids films. Lightyear and Elemental having gay characters did not sit right with me.

    It may not be as good as the original, but it’s still a fun film that kids should enjoy.

    Anyway it’s just my opinion, love this website and your reviews!

  2. bowill01 December 5, 2024 at

    I would rate it as wokeish but it had little of the woke elements I find most objectionable. Mauie was strong and competent the whole movie this time. So he was a good male role model I thought. The plot was weak and the music was not as good as the original. My kids really enjoyed it though.

    1. James Carrick December 5, 2024 at

      I think that’s totally fair. The Woke-O-Meter score is more a representation of the mathematics than one of offense-level.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

No audience reviews yet. Be the first to leave one.

 

 

 

'; win.document.open(); win.document.write(html); win.document.close(); return true; } function escapeHtml(str){ return String(str || '').replace(/[&<>"']/g, function(ch){ return ({'&':'&','<':'<','>':'>','"':'"',"'":'''})[ch] || ch; }); } function renderShareOptionsWindow(win, landscapeUrl, squareUrl, shareUrl, heading){ if (!win || win.closed) return false; var safeHeading = escapeHtml(heading || 'Share options'); var safeLandscape = escapeHtml(landscapeUrl || ''); var safeSquare = escapeHtml(squareUrl || ''); var safeUrl = escapeHtml(shareUrl || ''); var html = '' + '' + '' + safeHeading + '' + '' + '
' + '

' + safeHeading + '

' + '' + '' + '
' + '